MARKET ANALYSIS

The Grand Macallan Price Rally of 2016

5. July 2017 | 1.9K Views
Please note that this article is based on the old Whiskystats database.
Some numbers and figures may not match what you find in the Whiskystats 2.0 database.

We have already mentioned it at several occasions, but now it is time to take a closer look at the tremendous price increases we witnessed for the most traded Macallan single malts. What we call the “Grand Macallan Price Rally” clearly dominated the whisky auction year of 2016!

While the headlines of 2014 and 2015 focused on the price-explosion of japanese single malts, in 2016 the attention of the collectors shifted back to Scotland and Macallan in particular. In our Monthly Price Updates we witnessed how the Macallan distillery index reached one all-time peak after another.
 
From December 2015 to February 2017 the value of the 100 most traded Macallan single malts increased by 69,5%!
 
Furthermore, in the same time period there was only one month (June 2016) where the Macallan index did not rise. This also saw Macallan climbing up our distillery ranking and finally even overtaking Hanyu to now stand at the first place. In the subsequent months though, it seems like the Macallan Price Rally came to a hault. The index dropped by 7,5%. It now stands at 483,5 index points.
The Macllan Index In case you wonder about the periodic spikes in the years prior to 2015, there is an easy explanation for that. These spikes come from the Bonhams auctions which are not held on a monthly basis. At Bonhams we observe comparable few but high-priced trades which focus on very rare and collectable bottles. Consequently, Macallan belongs to the most traded distilleries at Bonhams. Especially the Macallan trades at Bonhams Hong Kong drastically exceeded the prices paid elsewhere. This caused the value of the 100 most traded Macallan bottlings to dramatically increase within one month. Then, in the following month, there came no price observations from Bonhams Hong Kong and hence this value decreased again. As we already mentioned in our introduction of the Hong Kong prices, these huge price differences became smaller over the recent years. In simple words, Macallan whiskies got more expensive everywhere.

The Rally by Markets

From above the question arises whether this Price Rally only affected single auction platforms. To find out, we calculated a different Macallan index for all the auction platforms we track. These indices reflect the change-in-value since December 2015 of the most traded Macallan bottlings of each platform. Of course for this we used price-observations from the respective platform solely, e.g. the below WhiskyAuction Macallan index was calculated by only using price observations from WhiskyAuction.com.
The Macallan Market Indices The conclusion seems to be pretty obvious. In all markets the value of the respective most traded Macallan bottlings climbed by around 40%. Above we saw that the overall Macallan index climbed by almost 70%. The “missing” 30% come from cross-effects. Interestingly, at WhiskyAuction.com prices climbed constantly from December 2015 to December 2016 and stayed at about the same level afterwards. At ScotchWhiskyAuctions.com Macallan prices even dropped in early 2016 but then climbed ever since.

The Guilty

After all those abstract indices we finally break the Macallan Price Rally down to the single bottle basis. Of course there are many bottlings which could be named here and we only point out some of them. In the below graphs you see the single price observations where the colour denotes the auction platform. Green and Red indicate Bonhams Edinburgh and Hong Kong, respectively. Yellow and Brown belong to WhiskyAuction.com and ScotchWhiskyAuctions.com. The blue line represents the monthly average prices.
 
Credit for all the bottle pictures belongs to WhiskyAuction.com!
 
First off there is the Macallan 18yo (1975). At the end of 2015 this whisky was worth around 750 Euros. One year later prices went as far as 2.500 Euros and settled in somewhere around 2.000 Euros.
The Macallan 18yo 1975 Another 18 years-old which we want to mention is the Macallan 18yo (1979) Giovinetti & Figli Import. Prices for this whisky climbed from 700 to 1.400 Euros within one year. Actually we found quite a lot of 18 years-old among the top performing Macallans. Another example would be the Macallan 18yo (1982) which also almost doubled in value.
The Macallan 18yo 1979 But it is not all 18 years-old. There is, for example, the Macallan 13yo (1997) Easter Elchies Cask Selection. Jugded on the below price observations this whisky seems to be particularly favoured by the bidders and sellers at ScotchWhiskyAcutions.com. Nevertheless, the highest price observation comes from WhiskyAuction.com. In December 2016 more than 1.500 Euros were paid for one of these bottles from cask 432.
The Macallan 13yo 1997 Of course we can always go rarer and more expensive. What about a Macallan distilled in 1946 and aged for more than half a century? You guessed right that this sounds expensive and even back in 2008 the Macallan 52yo (1946) Select Reserve was worth more than 2.000 Euros. The highest price-observation for this whisky comes from August 2015 where it was traded for around 15.000 Euros. Since the price dropped to 9.000 Euros at the end of 2015 and then climbed to more than 13.000 Euros in February 2017 this single malt also contributed to the proclaimed 2016 Price Rally.
The Macallan 52yo 1946 So prices for collectable Macallans increased significantly over the year of 2016. The obvious question is of course whether this will be repeated in 2017 or not. From our Macallan index we saw that prices just recently declined for three months in a row. Hence, it seems quite legit to say that this Price Rally is over. But who knows, maybe there is another one to come.

Found in Shops:
Macallan Gold /1824 Series Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky
70cl / 40% / Distillery Bottling - Macallan Gold was released in late 2012 as part of a series of colour-themed bottlings introduced to replace the distillery's age-statement expressions. Produced from 9-15yo first fill and refill sherry casks, it was designed to sit between the now-defunct 10yo Sherry Oak and 10yo Fine Oak bottlings.
Slightly Underprized
100 GBP Shop Price at The Whisky Exchange
115 GBP Estimated Market Value
Macallan 10 Year Old / Sherry Oak Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky
70cl / 40% / Distillery Bottling - Matured exclusively in oak sherry casks from Spain, Macallan 10yo is a deep, rich, deliciously smooth and well-rounded flavour with a slight sweetness and touch of sherry and wood. Its deep colour is achieved wholly naturally without the addition of any colouring.
Underprized
199 GBP Shop Price at The Whisky Exchange
275 GBP Estimated Market Value
Macallan 18 Year Old / Triple Cask / 2019 Release Speyside Whisky
70cl / 43% / Distillery Bottling - The 2019-release of Macallan's 18 Year Old triple-cask-matured single malt. Aged in a combination of sherry-seasoned European and American oak casks, as well as ex-bourbon casks, this is a fruity Highland single malt with notes of citrus, dried fruit, bitter cocoa and oak spice throughout the palate.
Fair Prized
250 GBP Shop Price at The Whisky Exchange
255 GBP Estimated Market Value